For The Engagement
Your unique proposal
Make your big moment a little sweeter by asking with a cookie. You design your proposal and we make it a reality in a hand-decorated piece of edible art.
Or think outside the box—with an edible ring box beautifully decorated to your specifications. It’s the sweetest way to pop the question.
For The Wedding Day
Favors or desserts
From the elegant to the whimsical, the possibilities are endless for custom cookies that perfectly reflect your wedding theme. Choose unique table favors for your guests in custom shapes and colors, floral designs, even metallic icing, or forego the traditional wedding cake and serve up personalized cookies as unique as you are.
For Graduation Day
Your special student
Incorporate those high school and college colors into a cookie design just for your graduate. We can reproduce any mascot, college logo or shield on our hand-decorated cookies. For the scholar, the athlete and the scholar-athlete, show your pride in your graduate with custom cookies by Sarah.
Call To Order
Custom Cookies by Sarah M.
“I create something unique for you!”
Cookies for every occasion—we supply that bit of sweet dessert, something extra special or that uniquely amazing themed cookie that perfectly completes your event. Whatever you want to say, say it with cookies from Custom Cookies by Sarah M.
All our custom cookies are decorated by hand by Sarah in her home-based bakery. From holidays to weddings, small orders to large, standard cookies, custom cookies or fully personalized cookies, we are limited only by your imagination. Need something completely unique? Ask us! We can do that!
Custom Cookies by Sarah M
Custom Cookies started in 2017 when owner Sarah Mentzer was approached about making 500 turtle cookies to help out an event. She took on the challenge and word quickly spread. Soon Sarah was making custom cookies for parties, celebrations, and unique events of friends, neighbors and organizations around the Akron area. Today, Sarah delivers 50 to 60 dozen cookies each week out of her home, some standard cookie trays, but most hand-decorated, custom orders made unique for each special occasion.